Big Cartel VS Shopify

Once upon a time in the vast realm of e-commerce, two mighty platforms emerged to revolutionize the way businesses sold their wares online. This epic battle between Big Cartel and Shopify would shape the landscape of online retail for years to come. Join us as we delve into the captivating history of these platforms, highlighting their differences and showcasing their unique features.

Our tale begins with Big Cartel, a plucky underdog that burst onto the scene in 2005. With a mission to empower artists and makers, Big Cartel sought to provide a simple yet powerful platform for creative entrepreneurs to showcase and sell their unique creations. Its focus on supporting small-scale businesses endeared it to countless artists seeking an online presence.

Big Cartel's journey was not without its challenges, though. As it gained popularity, it faced fierce competition from other e-commerce giants. However, its unwavering commitment to its niche market allowed it to carve out a special place in the hearts of artists worldwide.

On the other side of this digital battlefield stood Shopify, a formidable force that entered the fray back in 2006. Born out of frustration with existing e-commerce solutions, Shopify set out to create an all-in-one platform that could support businesses of all sizes. Its founders envisioned a world where anyone could effortlessly build an online store and reach customers far and wide.

Fuelled by this ambitious vision, Shopify quickly gained traction and became known for its user-friendly interface and robust feature set. Its extensive app store allowed businesses to customize their stores according to their unique needs, making it a go-to choice for entrepreneurs across various industries.

As both Big Cartel and Shopify grew in popularity, they each developed distinct characteristics that set them apart from one another. Let us explore these differences further.

Firstly, Big Cartel prided itself on simplicity. It offered a straightforward interface designed specifically for artists and makers who preferred an intuitive user experience. With its clean and minimalistic design, Big Cartel allowed users to focus on showcasing their products without overwhelming them with complex features. This simplicity made it an excellent choice for those seeking a hassle-free solution.

On the other hand, Shopify boasted a more comprehensive feature set. Its robust platform offered advanced tools for inventory management, order tracking, and analytics. With a wide range of themes and templates available, Shopify provided businesses with unparalleled customization options. Furthermore, its app store allowed users to extend the functionality of their stores, making it a versatile choice for businesses of all sizes.

Another crucial distinction between the two platforms lay in their pricing models. Big Cartel catered to artists and makers who were just starting their entrepreneurial journey or operating on a smaller scale. It offered free plans with limited features, allowing users to dip their toes into the world of e-commerce without breaking the bank. Additionally, Big Cartel's paid plans were reasonably priced and scaled according to the size of the business.

In contrast, Shopify positioned itself as a comprehensive solution for businesses at all stages of growth. Its pricing plans were tiered, offering increasing levels of functionality and support as businesses expanded. While this made Shopify a more expensive option for small-scale operations, it provided ample room for growth and access to advanced features that larger businesses required.

As time passed, both platforms continued to evolve and adapt to the ever-changing landscape of e-commerce. Big Cartel maintained its focus on supporting artists and makers while refining its user experience. It introduced new features such as inventory tracking and discount codes to cater to its growing user base.

Meanwhile, Shopify further solidified its position as an industry leader by constantly innovating and introducing new tools aimed at simplifying the online selling process. It expanded its offerings beyond just an e-commerce platform by adding features like point-of-sale systems and shipping integrations. This versatility allowed Shopify to serve brick-and-mortar stores looking to establish an online presence seamlessly.

Whether you are an artist seeking simplicity or an ambitious entrepreneur ready to conquer the digital realm, these two platforms continue to offer powerful solutions that can help bring your dreams to life. So, choose wisely, harness their strengths, and embark on your own epic e-commerce journey.

Big Cartel

  1. With Big Cartel, you can easily customize the look and feel of your store to match your brand.
  2. The platform provides SEO-friendly features to help improve your store's visibility in search engine results.
  3. It allows you to create your own online store to sell your unique products.
  4. The platform provides built-in tools for inventory management, order tracking, and shipping calculations.
  5. The platform provides analytics and sales reports to help you track the performance of your store.
  6. You can easily add product variations, such as different sizes or colors, to give customers more options.
  7. Big Cartel offers mobile apps for iOS and Android, allowing you to manage your store on the go.
  8. You can connect your social media accounts to promote your products directly from your Big Cartel store.
Sheldon Knows Mascot


  1. The platform supports multiple languages and currencies, allowing you to sell globally.
  2. You can choose from over 70 professional themes to design your store's appearance.
  3. Shopify has a dedicated support team available 24/7 to assist you with any technical issues or questions.
  4. It offers a mobile app that allows you to manage your store on the go and receive notifications about orders and inventory.
  5. You can customize your store's SEO settings to improve its visibility in search engine results.
  6. You can integrate Shopify with multiple social media platforms to promote your products and reach a wider audience.
  7. You can create customer accounts and offer personalized experiences through features like saved carts and wishlists.
  8. The platform offers various plugins and integrations to extend the functionality of your store.

Big Cartel Vs Shopify Comparison

Sheldon, the highly analytical and intellectually rigorous individual that he is, has determined that Shopify emerges as the victor against Big Cartel due to its broader range of features and superior scalability, thus providing a more efficient platform for anyone looking to start an online business. However, it should be noted that Sheldon's conclusions are subject to his personal bias and may not reflect the current market dynamics or the specific requirements of different users.