Shipt VS Instacart

Once upon a time in the bustling world of grocery delivery, two giants emerged to revolutionize the way people shopped for their everyday essentials. Shipt and Instacart, both pioneers in the industry, embarked on a fierce competition to capture the hearts and wallets of customers across the nation. In this epic tale, we delve into the history of these two titans and explore the key differences that set them apart.

Our story begins with Shipt, a trailblazer founded in 2014 by Bill Smith. With a mission to simplify grocery shopping, Shipt introduced a novel concept - delivering groceries straight to your doorstep. Harnessing the power of technology and an army of dedicated shoppers, Shipt quickly gained recognition for its exceptional service and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Meanwhile, Instacart was also making waves in the grocery delivery space. Founded by Apoorva Mehta in 2012, Instacart sought to bridge the gap between consumers and local grocery stores. Leveraging its innovative platform, Instacart connected customers with personal shoppers who handpicked their desired items from nearby stores. This unique approach garnered attention from consumers seeking convenience without compromising on quality.

Now, let's dive deeper into the differences that make Shipt and Instacart distinct from each other.

1. Retail Partnerships:

Shipt established exclusive partnerships with major retailers like Target and Meijer. This allowed Shipt to offer an extensive range of products from these retailers directly to customers' homes. On the other hand, Instacart collaborated with multiple retail partners such as Kroger, Costco, and Safeway. This breadth of partnerships provided Instacart users with access to a wider variety of stores.

2. Membership Model:

Shipt adopted a membership-based business model where customers paid an annual or monthly fee to access unlimited deliveries. This approach allowed Shipt members to enjoy free delivery on orders above a certain threshold. In contrast, Instacart offered a more flexible model, allowing customers to choose between a membership plan or pay per delivery. This flexibility appealed to those who preferred occasional grocery deliveries without committing to a long-term membership.

3. Availability:

Shipt initially focused on expanding its services in select metropolitan areas, gradually expanding its reach nationwide. This strategic approach ensured that Shipt could provide efficient and reliable service in specific regions before venturing into new markets. In contrast, Instacart took a broader approach from the start, aiming to cater to customers across various cities and states. This enabled Instacart to establish a widespread presence early on but occasionally led to variations in service quality.

4. Shopper Experience:

Both Shipt and Instacart relied on personal shoppers to fulfill customer orders. Shipt shoppers were exclusively dedicated to Shipt orders, providing a consistent experience for users. In contrast, Instacart shoppers often worked across multiple platforms simultaneously, potentially impacting their availability and efficiency when fulfilling Instacart orders.

5. Delivery Speed:

Shipt prided itself on its remarkable delivery speed, often promising same-day delivery within hours of placing an order. This rapid turnaround time delighted customers seeking immediate gratification. Instacart, while also offering same-day delivery options, occasionally faced longer delivery windows due to factors like shopper availability and order volume.

As the story unfolds, both Shipt and Instacart continued their relentless pursuit of innovation and excellence in the grocery delivery industry. They introduced features such as contactless delivery options, improved app interfaces, and enhanced customer support.

In recent years, the competition between these two giants intensified as they expanded their reach and improved their services. Shipt expanded its retailer partnerships beyond Target and Meijer, collaborating with regional chains like H-E-B and Publix. Meanwhile, Instacart solidified its position as a market leader by partnering with major retailers such as Walmart and CVS.


  1. Using Shipt saves you time and effort by eliminating the need to go to the grocery store yourself.
  2. You can communicate with your shopper in real-time through the app if you have any specific requests or preferences.
  3. Shipt ensures the freshness and quality of your groceries by using insulated bags during transportation.
  4. Shipt has a team of dedicated shoppers who carefully select and pack your groceries for delivery.
  5. The Shipt app allows you to easily browse and add items to your cart for convenient shopping.
  6. You can schedule deliveries at a time that works best for you, including evenings and weekends.
  7. The app provides live tracking, allowing you to see exactly where your shopper is and when they'll arrive.
  8. Shipt also offers special promotions and discounts on select items for its members.
Sheldon Knows Mascot


  1. It offers same-day delivery, allowing you to receive your groceries quickly.
  2. Instacart provides an easy-to-use platform for browsing and selecting your desired items.
  3. Instacart partners with various retailers, including supermarkets and specialty stores.
  4. You can order groceries from your favorite local stores through Instacart.
  5. You can choose from a wide range of products, including fresh produce, pantry staples, and household items.
  6. Instacart offers contactless delivery to ensure safety and convenience during the COVID-19 pandemic.
  7. You have the option to chat with your shopper during the fulfillment process for any necessary clarifications.
  8. You can customize your order by specifying preferences or adding special instructions for each item.

Shipt Vs Instacart Comparison

Sheldon concludes that the superior grocery delivery service is Instacart due to its broader availability and variety of stores, which align with Sheldon's meticulous purchasing criteria. Shipt, unfortunately, falls short in meeting his high standards with its limited store options and geographical reach.